Answer 2:
Why do mitochondria need DNA? Well, to
answer that
question, we would have go back in biological
evolutionary history some 2.1 to 2.7 billion years
ago (a wee bit longer than when I was in 7th
grade...) when bacteria (prokaryotes, or
prokaryotic cells) shared the earth with newly
evolved types of cells called eukaryotes (have you
learned yet what the differences between these two
types of cells are?)
Scientists believe
that eukaryotes somehow ingested or were
parasitized by the smaller prokaryotes, and that
when this happened the prokaryotes somehow (no one
knows how yet!) evaded being eaten by the
eukaryotes, and escaped being killed by the
eukaryotes' immune system (no one knows how yet!).
In fact, these prokaryotes actually provided such
a large benefit to the new host eukaryote, that
they were slowly (over many many generations)
incorporated into the necessary replication and
metabolism of the host cell. When two organisms
provide mutual benefit to one another, scientists
call this relationship a symbiosis. When one of
those organisms (the dependent cell) lives inside
the other one (the "boss cell" or host cell), this
symbiosis is more specifically called an
endosymbiosis (meaning inner symbiosis!). For
example, corals and the plant-like single cells
living within them (called dinoflagellates) form
an endosymbiosis.
However, unlike corals
and their endosymbiotic dinoflagellates, the
ancient original eukaryotic host cells and their
prokaryotic symbionts became very very dependent
on each other- to the point that now they now
cannot function without each other! Could we live
without mitochondria? Could mitochondria live
without our cells as their hosts? The answer is
definitely "no". In this situation, the host cell
and symbiont have become essentially one organism
over millions of years! However, the prokaryotes
(now mitochondria) kept some of their DNA (left
over from the time when they were free living
cells), and thus have the ability to replicate
certain types of proteins for use in the overall
functions of the cell. But remember, they are not
able to make all the types of proteins and enzymes
they need by themselves- many are made by the
nucleus.
So now, can you answer
why do mitochondria need DNA, and why don't other
organelles in a typical cell have DNA? (except of
course the nucleus). It all has to do with their
evolutionary history, doesn't it?
Now here
is a further question for you: What organelles do
photosynthesizing cells (plant-like) have that are
also thought to also be ancient prokaryotic
symbionts? (Hint: see Virginia Borden's
class
notes below). Also, I encourage you to look up
information on a very famous woman scientist named
Professor Lynn Margulis and her theory of
endosymbiosis for more information! She and her
collaborators overcame quite a bit of ridicule
from the scientific community in the 1960-80s when
she first proposed her theory.
Thanks
for asking a wonderful question! Always keep your
enthusiasm for asking questions about the way the
world works, and being an observant scientist. |