|
If you sent a marshmallow into space without a
spacesuit, would it explode or implode?
|
Question Date: 1998-03-17 | | Answer 1:
This is actually a very good question that is not
as simple to answer as it may seem. First, let me
tell you that the marshmallow will not implode. I
am not certain whether it will "explode" or not,
but I think that it probably will break apart to
some extent. Out in space, there is no
atmosphere, so things are a lot different than on
earth. Animals, plants, and objects that are
stable (do not explode or implode) on earth are
stable because they either have an internal
pressure that balances the pressure of the
atmosphere pushing in on them or they have a very
strong "shell" that keeps the object intact
despite the pressure difference between inside
and outside. Out in space, the absence of an
atmosphere means that there is no pressure pushing
in on an object, and if the object has a high
pressure inside of it and does not have a strong
shell, it will explode.
A good
example of this is a water balloon. If you filled
a balloon with water and put it out in space it
would likely explode since the pressure inside has
nothing outside of it to hold it together. This
is not entirely correct, since the balloon
material is holding the water in place. If the
material is strong enough, the balloon will stay
together. Otherwise, it will explode. So,
back to the Marshmallow. There probably will be
pockets of air within the Marshmallow that will
explode out in space, much like the water balloon.
Whether these will cause the marshmallow to
explode violently, I am not sure. The answer
probably will be different for different
marshmallows.
| | Answer 2:
One answer:Marshmallows have quite a bit of air
whipped into them during the manufacturing
process. As the pressure decreases as you go into
space, the gas inside the marshmallow would
expand, sort of like a balloon being blown up. At
some point, the marshmallow would explode, just
like the balloon. You can do the same thing with
a balloon as it goes up into the atmosphere - the
balloon expands and eventually pops if it gets
high enough. | | Answer 3:
It would do neither. In fact, the marshmallow
would freeze and become very brittle like a piece
of rigid plastic. You could then shatter it into
many small pieces !! The pressure above the
atmosphere is essentially zero. The pressure at
the earths surface is 100000 pascals or what we
call 1 atm pressure. The marshmallow would not
expand very much due to this difference in
pressure because marshmallows, like most solids,
are pretty incompressible. Look this word up!!
Incompressible means that even when you squeeeze
an object, it doesnt densify too much. A GAS, on
the otherhand, is an example of a COMPRESSIBLE
material...if the pressure changes, the density of
the gas WILL change a lot. This is what happens
when one climbs a mountain and goes upwards above
sea level--the density of the air decreases
towards zero in the vacuum of space. Of course, a
marshmallow, unlike a solid object, has some
porosity (tiny holes filled with air). Do an
experiment: is the density of a marshmallow
greater than or smaller than that of ordinary tap
water at room temp and 1 atmosphere pressure???
| | Answer 4:
Wow, that's a doozy of a question. First, you
have to think about why something would explode or
implode. When things explode, the pressure on the
inside is higher than the outside. When things
implode the pressure on the outside is higher than
the inside. What happens if you shake a can of
soda and then open it really fast? It sprays all
over the place. That's because by shaking it,
you've released a bunch of gas and that increases
the pressure on the _inside_ of the can. So, when
you open the can, it squirts out. Also, try
filling your cheeks with air and puckering your
lips to hold the air in. Then have someone slowly
push on your cheecks. Can you feel the pressure
build up? Then, when that pressure is high
enough, the air gets squeezed out of your
mouth.
So...back to your question.
What is a marshmellow? It's a bunch of sugar with
little air pockets in it. Is there any air in
space? Nope. So, which is going to have the
higher pressure, space or the marshmellow? The
answer is the marshmellow. So that means the
marshmellow would explode if you sent it into
space.
Here's a bonus question: What
happens if you send a marshmellow to the bottom of
the ocean?
| | Answer 5:
Good question! This actually involves a pretty
complicated combination of effects. One is that
all the air inside the marshmallow tries to escape
since it is now in vacuum. It is not clear to me
whether the air would escape explosively or not.
It would depend on the marshmallow molecular
structure. Another effect is that the escaping
air and radiation will cause the marshmallow to
cool quickly. Perhaps this would cause the
marshmallow to shrink up. Of course, there could
be a big difference between whether the
marshmallow is in the sun or in the shade when put
into space. We've agreed here in the lab that the
best thing to do is to try to rig up a test. I'll
let you know when I have some
results. .... Two weeks
later...
Results of tests I've
run:
1) Marshmallow in liquid nitrogen
(-196 degrees Celsius)
I dipped the
marshmallow in liquid nitrogen for a few minutes
until it seemed like the marshmallow was at liquid
nitrogen temperature. It got brittle and hard and
when I crushed it, little pieces broke off. It
never really shattered though.
2)
Marshmallow in a vacuum chamber
We put a
couple marshmallows in a bell jar (clear glass
vacuum chamber). When pumping down with a vacuum
pump the marshmallow expanded to about double it's
size and then, after a minute or so, shrank back
down a little bit. When we opened up the bell jar
again the marshmallow immediately contracted to
about half its original size.
3)
Marshmallow in liquid nitrogen and then quickly
placed into vacuum chamber
The marshmallow
didn't expand this time the way it did before.
When I took the marshmallow out of the chamber it
stayed the same size as it was before. The
marshmallow had cracks in it and it was pretty
easy to break into pieces (it was still cold).
These three tests seem to me to be the
easiest way to mimic the possible effects of
putting a marshmallow into space. It is probably
the case that the marshmallow would lose all its
air before it has cooled down very much. So with
these tests in mind what do you think would happen
if you put a marshmallow into space? How exactly
would you put a marshmallow in space and how might
the way you do it affect the
results?
| | Answer 6:
I should say right out front that I am not a
marshmallow expert. I haven't studied the science
of marshmellow-ology, neither am I accredited by
any national marshmallow research agencies. That
said, here is my answer. As I understand it a
marshmallow is pretty much the same as a sponge or
a rice crispy (not in the way they taste, but in
the way they are put together). The structure of
all of these things is also like a foam. If you
look at your bath when you have a lot of soap in
the water you will notice that huge mounds of suds
form. Those mounds, if you look at them closely,
are made up of thousands of tiny bubbles.
Now, with marshmellows, rice crispies, or
sponges the same thing is happening except that
the wall of the bubble is made out of marshmellow,
or rice crispy, or sponge. If you look very
closely at any of these things you will see that
they are made up of thousands of tiny bubbles of
material all jammed together."That's great," you
are probably saying by now, "but what does that
have to do with whether a marshmallow explodes or
not?" To answer that I'll need to give two
examples. The first is something that certainly
_would_ explode in outer space, a soap bubble. Now
a soap bubble doesn't burst down here in the
atmosphere because the air pressure inside the
bubble is the same as the air pressure outside. As
you go higher and higher there is less and less
air, therefore lower and lower air pressure. Once
you get to outer space there is practically no air
at all so the air pressure outside of the bubble
is almost zero. If we were to take a soap bubble
from your bath and raise it up higher and higher
it would expand, because the air pushing from the
inside would be pushing harder than the air from
the outside. Once it had stretched as far as the
soap could stretch it would burst.
My
other example is a whiffle ball. You might at
first glance say that a whiffle ball is a lot like
a soap bubble, they are both round at least. But
as I take the whiffle ball higher and higher the
air inside it, instead of pushing on the sides of
the whiffle ball and making it expand, just rushes
out the holes. If I take it all the way into space
the whiffle ball would be just fine, only it
wouldn't have any air in it any more.
Now
back to marshmellows. When the marshmellow is
first formed it is made out of some white gooey
liquid. Just after it is formed into the
marshmellow shape it is a lot like a collection of
soap bubbles. If you were to take it into space at
that point you better be prepared to make
interstellar rice crispy treats because you'd have
marshmellow everywhere. You may have noticed,
however, that is not what the marshmellow looks
like when you take it out of the bag. It's
basically just a soft, fluffy ball. That is
because it has dried, and as it dried all of the
little bubbles that make up the marshmellow go
from having liquid walls to squishy semi-solid
walls. In its dried form a marshmellow looks a lot
more like a collection of thousands of tiny, soft,
whiffle balls than tiny soap bubbles. So my answer
is no, I don't think it will explode. But then
again I haven't tried it, so who
knows?
*When I'm talking about sponges in
my answer above I mean sponges that are made
synthetically. There are animals called sponges
that live in the ocean and they grow by a totally
different process. If you want to know more about
"aquatic" (meaning water-living) sponges the
encyclopedia is a good place to start.
| | Answer 7:
A marshmallow in outer space would explode for
sure! The physical science instructor at Allan
Hancock College in Santa Maria does a demo for his
class in which he takes a glob of whipped cream
and places it in a glass bubble that he can suck
the air out of, making it nearly a vacuum, like in
outer space. Wow, you should see that whipped
cream expand!
What would happen if you took
a marshmallow down to the bottom of the ocean in a
submarine? (OK, let's say you put it in a plastic
bag to protect it from the water so it won't
dissolve!)
| | Answer 8:
Actually, I have never thought in sending a
marshmellow into space... (1)The more you go
up in altitude, the less pressure you have,
(2) In space, there is the vacuum. So any
object sent to space should explode.
Click Here to return to the search form.
|
|
|
|
|
Copyright © 2020 The Regents of the University of California,
All Rights Reserved.
UCSB Terms of Use
|
|
|