|
Why can't we see stars in the day time like we do
at night?
|
Question Date: 1998-04-13 | | Answer 1:
During the day the stars are still there, you just
can't see them because the sky is so bright. For
example, it's a lot easier to see the glow of a
candle in the dark than in the light. It is
always hard to sense small changes to something
that is already big to start with. For example,
in a noisy room you probably can't hear a dripping
faucet, but when everything else is quiet then you
can hear the drip, even though the dripping hasn't
gotten any louder. Its just easier to hear
something soft in a silent background, than it is
to hear something soft in a noisy background.
In the same way it's easier to see the dim
starlight with a dark background than it is to see
the same dim starlight on a bright background.
| | Answer 2:
Try noticing the sky at night during the next
month.Compare how many stars you can see now, when
the moon is not up (until around midnight or
later), to a few weeks from now when the moon is
full again. Now imagine having the sun in the sky
instead of the full moon. How many stars do you
think you should be able to see?
You could
also watch the sky as the sun is setting. As the
sky begins to darken, when can you first see
stars? How bright does the sky seem to be at this
time when compared with daytime? Once the sky is
fully dark, how bright are the first stars you
could see compared to the rest of the stars in the
sky?
| | Answer 3:
The reason that you cannot see stars during the
daytime is that the sun's rays overpower the faint
light we see from the stars. During the night,
when the sun's rays are blocked by the other side
of the earth, it is possible to see the faint
light of the stars shining in space. You can
watch this transition if you watch the sunset on a
clear night, as the sun's rays become fainter and
fainter (and it becomes dawn on the other side of
the earth), you can begin to see the first hint of
the brightest stars. You will also notice that,
generally speaking, the first stars to appear will
be those farthest away from the setting sun (where
the sky is darkest at that time).
Hope that
helps!
| | Answer 4:
This question can be partially answered by several
effects. First, the human eye is sensitive to
light over an enormous range of intensities.
Typical "bright" stars are actually very dim
compared to the brightness of the sun -- about a
trillion 10^12 times dimmer. The brightness of
objects illuminated by the sun typically 10 to 100
times dimmer than it is -- but that still makes
the an enormous problem for the eye. (It has at
least two mechanisms for light accommodation-- the
iris which simple stops a fraction of the light
like a camera lens, and chemical changes which
enhance the cells particular to night vision. --
this takes some 10 to 20 minutes and unless you
walk rapidly from dim to bright or vice versa you
won't notice it.) So the first problem is that
your eye -- to allow you to see, will reduce its
sensitivity when there is bright light
present.
Secondly, the atmosphere of the
earth has lots of fine particles of dust which are
so small they never settle to the ground. These
dust particles scatter a small part of the light
from the sun in random directions, and the
mechanism for scattering works better for shorter
(bluer) wavelengths. This is why the sky is blue
and why the sun seems to redden as it sets -- it
has a longer path in the air -- so more of the
blue light is lost, then green ... etc. By the
way, clouds are made of much bigger bits, so they
scatter visible light fairly evenly -- making them
appear white. (But not to even longer light like
infrared -- which can peer through
clouds).
Both processes make seeing stars
in the daytime very hard. However, if you happen
to be in a deep well, with dark walls so that you
only see a small bit of sky, and the rest of you
visual field is dark, you might see some bright
stars during the day.... So, do you think that the
astronauts can see the stars during the day from
the moon? | | Answer 5:
The reason we can't see the stars during the day
is because when the sun is up, it is so much
brighter than the stars that our eyes can't pick
them out of the sky. You might think that you
could see stars during the day if you looked AWAY
from the sun, but the sun's light is spread out
all over the sky by our atmosphere, which is part
of the reason why the sky is blue during the day
(it's clear at night, right?)
Here's a
question for you. Stars, just like the sun, tend
to rise in the east and set in the west. Why do
they do that?
If that's too easy, here's a
much harder question. The sun rises in the east
and sets in the west. But in the summer, the sun
rises in the northeast and sets in the northwest,
and in the winter the sun rises in the southeast
and sets in the southwest. (In the spring and
fall, the sun rises and sets more or less directly
in the east and west.) How or why does this
happen? (Drawing pictures may help.) | | Answer 6:
In the day the stars are still there, but you
cannot see them because they are so much fainter
than the sunlight that is scattered by our
atmosphere. If the Earth had no atmosphere, then
our daytime sky would be black like at night,
except the sun would be a huge spotlight shining
down at us. In such an unpleasant world we might
see stars during the day. But since we have an
atmosphere, the sun's light scatters and gives us
a beautiful blue glow from all over, not just from
where the sun is. In other words, even if you
look away from the sun you are still seeing the
sun's light that has bounced off of some particle
in the atmosphere, and that light is much brighter
than the light from the stars.
Maybe your
teacher can help you try to find out what the
particles are in our atmosphere that scatter the
sun's light and why the scattered light is blue!
WHY IS THE SKY BLUE?
| | Answer 7:
It is possible to see a few of the brightest stars
during the day. In fact, there is one star that
can sometimes be seen during the daytime, but can
never be seen at night! Can you guess which one?
(Hint -- it's the closest star.)
There are
at least two problems with observing stars during
the day time. First, stars are very faint
compared to the light from the sun (the nearest
star). Our eyes are adjusted to sunlight during
the day, and much less sensitive. Not only does
the iris of the eye contract from the high
intensity sunlight, but the retina becomes much
less sensitive to light as well. A clear sky is
transparent to starlight, but the blue color from
scattered sunlight is bright enough to overpower
feeble stars.
The other problem is that
your eye has difficulty focusing to infinity when
you are looking at a featureless blue sky. If you
are trying to see small, faint things like stars
it is critical that your eye be focused precisely.
However, if you look at a blue sky there is no
reference object for your eye to focus on and it
is difficult to correctly focus on a star.
Nevertheless, it is possible to see some
stars in daylight. The stars must be bright, such
as Sirius, Arcturus, Vega, Capella, Rigel, etc.
You also need to know exactly where to look, in
advance. Finally, it helps if there is some very
distant object right next to the star that you can
focus your vision on. Aldebaran is a good star to
try to see because it lies near the plane of the
ecliptic, and the moon passes very near it once
every 28 days. (Often the moon occults Aldebaran,
that is, it passes between the Earth and the
star.) If the moon is very near Aldebaran during
the day, you just might be able to see it if you
have good eyesight.
Click Here to return to the search form.
|
|
|
|
|
Copyright © 2020 The Regents of the University of California,
All Rights Reserved.
UCSB Terms of Use
|
|
|