|
Imagine that you make contact with an
extraterrestrial intelligence. What units would
you use to communicate ideas about how our
planet or solar system operates? It seems that
the units of time, distance, and mass which we
use are based on features of our own system and
wouldn't necessarily make sense to an
intelligence from somewhere else (e.g. Second,
Hour, Day, Year, Lightyear, AU, Kilogram, Meter,
are all arbitrary or based on the location or
movement of the Earth). What are units which
anyone from our universe (but not necessarily
our planet) would be able to recognize?
|
Question Date: 2012-04-30 | | Answer 1:
That's a great question and quite a
challenging one. A simple analogy is to think
how you might communicate with a species like a
dolphin. They are obviously intelligent and
have a complicated system of communication, but
we are not able to decipher it. Most attempts at
communication with extraterrestrials therefore
work on the assumption that any highly
intelligent species would understand mathematics
and rely on simple codes to show signs of
intelligence on our end.
One example of an early attempt on the Voyager
probe can be found here.
click here
In this attempt, they try to tie the code of
the message to fundamental physical phenomena,
such as the hydrogen atom, in the hope that any
intelligent species would have a highly
developed knowledge of the physical world.
There are obviously big assumptions in these
messages and the probability of success is
completely unknown.
Note that some observers such as Stephen
Hawking have suggested the whole notion of
contacting an advanced species may be a bad idea
in general:
hawking-
aliens
| | Answer 2:
That is a fantastic question that has
intrigued a lot of physicists. These systems
of "Natural Units" have only fundamental
physical constants as their basis. The most
popular are Planck Units, which are based off
the Planck constant, which is a fundamental
physical constant (it appears all over the
place, and doesn't change, kind of like the
value Pi). For this system, all units are based
on the Planck constant, the gravitational
constant, and the speed of light, all of which
are identical anywhere in the universe.
We could imagine other systems as well, and
they are often used in chemistry and physics for
making calculations in a more simple way. For
example, units of energy are often expressed in
Rydberg (the amount of energy required to remove
the electron from hydrogen), units of length in
Bohr radii (the average orbital distance of
hydrogen's electron), and units of mass in
Daltons (the approximate mass of one proton or
neutron).
The only thing is that our system of encoding
these numbers would still be unintelligible to
any alien life. (Some people would even argue
that math is unintelligible to most human life.)
| | Answer 3:
The elements are the same everywhere, so you
could try to communicate about how the lightest
element has 1 proton and 1 electron, and then
there other elements that have 2 protons and 2
electrons - or maybe just the relative masses of
the elements would be useful. Here, check out
this link from NIST, with atomic weights, in
whole numbers, of 1 - 4 - 7 - 9 - 11 - 12 - 14 -
16 ...
click here
Other scientists have asked the same questions
you are asking. On November 16, 1974, they
broadcasted a message into space with the sort
of information you are talking about. This
message is called the Arecibo message, and you
can read about it here:
arecibo message
Do you think this is a good message? What do
you think are the strongest parts and the
weakest parts?
Keep asking questions!
Best wishes,
| | Answer 4:
We know that it's iron chiefly because we
know how dense it is. The density is measurable
by how well it transmits sound waves, as well as
by measuring the gravitational field of the
Earth: if the Earth were made of solid rock, for
example, gravity would be half as strong at the
surface as it is. If the core were made out of
lead, then gravity would be stronger.
Also, iron is the most common reasonably
dense metal in the universe (because of how
nuclear fusion works in stars), so it makes
sense that the core is mostly iron.
Click Here to return to the search form.
|
|
|
|
|
Copyright © 2020 The Regents of the University of California,
All Rights Reserved.
UCSB Terms of Use
|
|
|