|
Why are some people visual learners and some
people auditory learners? How can you test them
to
find out which one they are? Thank you!
|
Question Date: 2012-10-18 | | Answer 1:
I´m very happy to see this question! The short
answer is this: there really isn´t any scientific
evidence that some people are "visual learners"
and some people are "auditory learners." Whether
people score as more visual or more auditory on a
test, everyone probably learns in about the same
way!
To understand where this evidence comes from,
let´s talk about the scientific method. First, a
scientist asks a question. In the case of
learning
styles, the question is, "Do some people learn
better from a visual lesson, while others learn
better from an auditory lesson?" Next, the
scientist forms a hypothesis, which is what they
think the answer to their question will be. Our
scientist´s hypothesis could be, "People who
score
as visual learners will do better on a test if
they learn with a visual lesson. People who score
as auditory learners will do better on a test if
they learn with an auditory lesson." Great! Now
the scientist can design a study to test this. A
good study would look like this:
1. Give students a test to determine if they
are
visual or auditory learners. The test could
include questions like, "I follow written
instructions better than oral instructions."
2. Randomly mix the students into two groups.
Give one group an auditory lesson, and give the
other group a visual lesson.
3. Give all of the students a test of the
material presented in the lesson.
According to the scientist´s prediction, the
visual learners who get a visual lesson and the
auditory learners who get an auditory lesson
should learn the best, whereas the students who
get a lesson that doesn´t match their learning
style should perform very poorly.
As it turns out studies like this have been
done,
and our scientist´s hypothesis was incorrect.
According to these studies, students all learn
about the same with either lesson, whether they
initially score as a visual or an auditory
learner! People score differently on tests of
learning styles because they might prefer one
type
of lesson over the other, but that doesn't
actually predict anything about learning.
If it´s not learning styles, then what helps
people learn? People learn well when they
elaborate on information in their heads, and when
they generate connections with their prior
knowledge. There are lots of important things
that
make us unique as students, but whether we learn
better with visual or auditory information
probably isn´t one of them.
For a review of this research, see Pashler,
H.,
McDaniel, M., Rohrer, D., & Bjork, R. (2008).
Learning styles: Concepts and evidence.
Psychological Science in the Public Interest,
9(3), 105-119.
| | Answer 2:
Jenna, this is a fantastic question! While I
don't think this concept is really understood at
a fundamental level, I think that part of it is
because of how our brains "allocate"
information.
What I mean by "allocate" is: how much space,
or how many brain cells, we have available for
each type of information we want to store. It
turns out that our brains are divided into
different "parts" called "lobes" and "cortices"
according to the kind of information we're
dealing with.
So for your question, the kinds of
information we're dealing with are visual versus
audio information. It turns out that some people
have a larger "visual cortex" and a
smaller "auditory cortex," whereas other people
might have the exact opposite. The visual and
auditory cortices are the regions of the brain
where we deal with visual or auditory
information, respectively. In fact, your visual
cortex is located in the back, top part of your
head, and your auditory cortex is located more
on the sides, near your temples!
In terms of testing people to see whether
they learn better through sight or hearing, you
could try performing an experiment like this:
1. show someone a bunch of numbers, shapes,
or items. For example, "5, 2, circle (draw
this), 73, banana (draw this), chair, 61,
triangle, 98, 46, star"
2. ask them to write down as much as they
can remember, or give them a piece of paper with
some of them as multiple choice answers.
3. now, verbally list a new set of numbers,
shapes, or items: For instance: "18, diamond,
35, 11, muffin, 24, desk, 56, tree"
4. ask them to write down as much as they
can remember, or give them a piece of paper with
some of them as multiple choice answers.
Now compare how many they got correct! I hope
this helps. Have fun!
| | Answer 3:
The three most common types of learning
styles are visual, auditory, and kinesthetic. To
learn, we depend on our senses to process the
information around us. Most people tend to use
one of their senses more than the others.
Visual learners learn through seeing. These
learners need to see the teacher's body language
and facial expression to fully understand the
content of a lesson. They tend to prefer sitting
at the front of the classroom to avoid visual
obstructions (e.g. people's heads). They may
think in pictures and learn best from visual
displays including: diagrams, illustrated
textbooks, videos, hand-outs, etc. During a
lecture or classroom discussion, visual learners
often prefer to take detailed notes to absorb
the information.
Auditory learners learn through listening.
They learn best through verbal lectures,
discussions, talking things through and
listening to what others have to say. Auditory
learners interpret the underlying meanings of
speech through listening to tone of voice,
pitch, speed and other nuances. Written
information may have little meaning until it is
heard. These learners often benefit from reading
text aloud and using a tape recorder.
Kinesthetic learners learn through moving,
doing, and touching. They learn best through a
hands-on approach, actively exploring the
physical world around them. They may find it
hard to sit still for long periods and may
become distracted by their need for activity and
exploration.
Everyone is different and therefore we all
naturally have different learning styles. But
typically our learning style is forced upon us
through life like this: In grades kindergarten
to third, new information is presented to us
kinesthetically; grades 4 to 8 are visually
presented; while grades 9 to college and on into
the business environment, information is
presented to us mostly through auditory means,
such as lectures. Many people would argue that
throughout schooling and beyond information
should be presented in all three ways: visually,
through auditory means, and kinesthetically.
You can take a test to see which learning
style you have here: learning style
Click Here to return to the search form.
|
|
|
|
|
Copyright © 2020 The Regents of the University of California,
All Rights Reserved.
UCSB Terms of Use
|
|
|