Answer 1:
Since science is primarily based on the
observation and description of the natural world,
science does not yet really tell us why certain
things happen at the most basic level.
Electromagnetism is one of these basic ideas
that is known to be true (and has been studied for
more than 200 years!), and modern scientists have
a very good idea about how electric and magnetic
effects are related. The question of why these
effects are so tightly linked has remained
extremely hard to prove.
We can, however, use the relationships between
electricity and magnetism that have been developed
to explain many interesting things that happen in
the world around us! For example, scientists can
tell exactly how far a compass needle will deflect
when placed near a wire that is carrying
electricity. We can also use these ideas to make
many important technologies, such as hard disc
drives for computers.
I know that electromagnetism can be tricky to
think about - I certainly think so! - but I hope
that I have been able to help answer your
question. Please send along any other questions
that come to mind!
|
Answer 2:
This is an excellent question and one which has
two answers, neither of which is a very good
answer. But knowing the two answers and how they
relate gets to the very heart of what science is
and can help us realize just how wonderful and
amazing the universe can be. Sounds like a tall
order right... well, let me try to explain.
So I said that there are two answers to your
question. Both are completely right and 100% true,
so far as we can tell, and they've been tested
quite a bit. Understanding both these answers, and
how they can both be true is what discovering the
universe is all about. But let's get to these
answers already. I'll start with the longer
answer, so that you can keep it in mind while
reading the shorter answer. The question is "can
you explain to me how electric currents can
produce magnetic effects, and how magnets can
cause electric currents?" and if you're asking
what is it about electric currents that cause
magnetic effects, and what is it about magnets
that cause electric currents, then the answer is
that I can provide no insight on those questions.
I cannot explain why these things are the case,
and it's not for lack of study. The truth is that
nobody can answer those questions. The fact of the
matter is that scientists have studied these
things at great length, and we know that it is
indeed the case, that when a magnet moves in
proximity to a loop of wire, it exerts a force on
the electrons within that loop which causes a
current. We know that it happens and we can
explain what exactly is happening and have very
carefully calculated values for how much current
will flow for a given magnet in a given situation.
We know all those things very precisely. (That is
basically the second answer, which I will go into
a little bit later.) But the fact still remains
that we are only describing what we see (or
observe) in nature.
The fact of the matter is that electric and
magnetic fields are one in the same, an electrical
charge (like an electron) in motion causes a
magnetic field, and a magnetic field in motion
causes an electric field. But why this is the case
can only be answered by the words... "The universe
is that way". The force responsible for both
electrical effects and magnetic effects is called
the electro-magnetic force (I wonder where they
got the name, right?!?). Scientists call it one of
4 fundamental forces (actually in reality there
are 3 fundamental forces, but in the world as we
see it 1 of those forces splits off to behave in
two different ways... but that's a detail you can
ignore until you start doing a Ph.D. in physics).
We call these forces fundamental because they
exist and are not caused by anything else. Gravity
is another fundamental force. It's true that
gravity comes from large massive objects, like the
earth, but if you ask why mass produces gravity,
the answer is just because that's the way the
world works. Matter pulls other matter towards it
through gravity. Just like a moving electron
produces a magnetic field. It's just a funny
little thing that the universe does. And to try to
understand why this is the case is sort of like
asking what color is my voice. It's the wrong sort
of question to be asking.
Scientists have spent a lot of their time
figuring out how electro-magnetism works, but none
would even try to answer why it works. As far as
we know, the universe could have made had it some
other way. The fact that everything works out so
nicely and life seems to work out well for us
seems almost unlikely, given the the universe
could have been any other way. To some, this is
proof that something must have created, at least
the rules of the universe. To others, the universe
is this way because if it were any other way, then
we wouldn't be around to ask the question of why
the universe seems to work out so nicely. This is
called the anthropic principle.
Many scientists believe that our universe is
just one of many, that either exist at the same
time as ours, or have existed at some point in the
past. In any universe where the conditions aren't
right for life, there just won't be any life to
observe that universe, and so we'll never know
about it. For examples, if there is a universe
where electrons don't repel each other, which by
the way, is what keeps you from passing through
solid objects, then we would never know because
life wouldn't be able to develop there and so we
wouldn't know about it.
So, that's the long answer: I cannot explain it
because it simply is how the universe works.
That's the puzzle scientists grapple with
everyday. Read the next answer on Answer 3
below.
|
Answer 3:
The other answer relates to how electric
effects produce magnetic ones and viceversa. As I
mentioned, electric and magnetic phenomena are
tightly coupled. You can think of them as two
sides of the same coin. It's not really that one
causes the other, they just happen to always go
together. Scientists have observed that a changing
electric field creates a magnetic field. So, if
you have a circuit and you send AC current through
(AC = Alternating current) so that the electrons
move back and forth, they will create a changing
electric field. This produces a magnetic field
(because that's what the universe does). Similarly
a changing magnetic field creates an electric
field. Luckily enough we have a changing magnetic
field, we just created it with our AC current. It
went from 0 to some non-zero amount, and so that
change is enough to create an electric field. And,
as you can guess, the creation of that electric
field creates a magnetic field, etc. etc. There is
a good illustration of it on this web site.
EM
propagation
We can also write equations to give us precise
measurements for how strong the fields are, but
all the equations we have for electromagnetics are
empirical. That means that we went out into the
world and measured things, and then found a
formula that seems to agree with all of the data
we collected. But as far as we can tell, our
equations do pretty well. It's also important to
note that while electromagnetic waves can travel
through materials by jiggling around the electrons
as the wave passes through, the material is not
necessarily. Electromagnetic waves can travel
through complete vacuum (ie: nothingness, no air,
no material, no anything). It's a good thing
that's the case, because the electromagnetic waves
coming from the sun (light and heat) need to
travel through the nothingness of space to reach
us.
So, that is my answer to your question: I can
describe what's happening, but I cannot explain
it. Changing Electric fields produce magnetic
fields and viceversa. That's the way the universe
works.
Thanks for the question. Click Here to return to the search form.
|