|
Why does carbon dioxide in a solid state sublime?
|
Question Date: 2013-08-29 | | Answer 1:
Thank you for your question "Why does carbon
dioxide in a solid state sublime?". This
phenomenon can be explained by looking at a type
of graph that is known as a Phase Diagram. Phase
diagrams are graphs that show what physical states
(solid, liquid, or gas) a certain type of matter
will exist in at a given pressure and temperature.
The link below shows a phase diagram for water.
water
phase diagram
In the phase diagram, the y-axis is pressure
(in atmospheres, or atm) and the x-axis is
temperature (in Celsius). If you select a certain
pressure and temperature combination and find that
point on the graph, that point will sit in the
region that corresponds to the physical state of
matter that the material will exist in. If you
start at the y-axis, at the pressure of 1
Atmosphere (normal ambient pressure), and draw a
horizontal line across the graph (increasing
temperature), you will see that water goes from
ice (below 0 Celsius) to water (0-100 Celsius) and
finally to vapor (above 100 Celsius).
Now we will look at carbon dioxide. The link
for the phase diagram of CO2 is below;
we have several phase diagrams there, please look
for the CO2:
carbon
dioxide phase diagram
If you draw a horizontal line across the graph
at a pressure of 1 atmosphere, you will see that
carbon dioxide goes directly from a solid to a gas
(sublimes!) at a very low temperature of -78.5
Celsius. Carbon dioxide physically cannot exist as
a liquid at atmospheric pressure. So, when you see
a chunk of dry ice (solid CO2), and you
observe that there is gaseous CO2
coming off of it, this happens because the surface
of the dry ice is in contact with the room
temperature air (at ~22 Celsius) and so the
molecules on the surface of the dry ice block
immediately go from the solid state to the gaseous
state.
Now, why this phenomenon happens is a little
more complicated, and has to do with the
intermolecular forces between
CO2 molecules. CO2 is a
non-polar molecule, and the molecules are
attracted to each other only by a very weak force
called the "van der Waals" force. Since the
molecules are very weakly attracted to each other,
CO2 molecules very readily go from the
solid state to the gas state at low temperatures.
I hope this helps with your question!
Sincerely,
| | Answer 2:
Great question! The process of phase
transitions depends largely on the material
properties of the molecule. Intermolecular forces
(bonds) play a large role in determining when and
how a substance changes phases. Generally, the
phase depends on two factors: temperature and
pressure.
Plotting the phases on a graph with
these two factors as axes is called a
[pressure-temperature] phase diagram. Most
compounds show three phases when cooling at a
constant, room pressure (i.e. water), but
sometimes compounds like carbon dioxide skip the
liquid phase altogether and transition directly to
a solid when cooled. This is because the pressure
at normal atmosphere is too low for carbon dioxide
to condense to a liquid. However, we can isolate
the gas in a high-pressure vessel and then cool it
to exhibit a liquid phase. Nevertheless, many
materials can exhibit wildly different phase
behaviors. For instance, if you had water at high
pressure and at 0 degrees Celsius and decreased
the pressure, the order of phases would be liquid
-> solid -> vapor!
| | Answer 3:
Any solid sublimes, actually; it's just that
carbon dioxide has a fairly high rate of it. The
temperature of the Earth is also too warm for
carbon dioxide to be stable as a solid, so it
vaporizes. The process is very similar to boiling,
except that the atmospheric pressure is too low to
allow carbon dioxide to become a liquid, so it
"boils" directly from solid to gas.
Note: I invite you to go and visit the
east side of the Sierra Nevada during the winter.
It is a desert, so the humidity is low enough that
any body of water continually evaporates
(sublimes), but in winter it is also cold at least
high enough, so the snow that falls can evaporate
directly into the air. It's the same process as
carbon dioxide, but of course snow is water, not
dry ice.
| | Answer 4:
That is a good question! In short, it is all
about pressure. We usually think of melting
and boiling as something that happens at a fixed
temperature, but it actually depends on pressure
just as much as temperature. You might have heard
that it is harder to cook at high elevations like
in the Andes or the Himalaya. This is because
there is less air (lower pressure) at high
elevations. At lower pressures, water boils at
lower temperatures, so it takes longer to cook food!
If the pressure is low enough, water-ice
(HO) will also sublime. Dry ice
(CO2) works the same way. It sublimes,
because the pressure at the surface of the Earth
is too low for liquid CO2. If you could
take the dry ice to a place where the pressure is
much higher (like the bottom of the ocean, or a
special laboratory) you could actually watch it
melt, then boil, just like H2O at the
surface of the Earth.
Please click on this
link
to see an interesting picture related to the
different states of
CO2
| | Answer 5:
That is a get question. Solid carbon dioxide
does indeed sublime rather than melt first and
then turn into a gas. This has to do with the
bonds that hold carbon dioxide together. The
carbon dioxide molecule is symmetric with an
oxygen molecule at either end of a carbon
molecule. This means that the molecule has no
electric dipole, there is no one side of the
molecule that is more positive or more negative
than another part of the molecule. This means that
the attraction forces between stable molecules is
not very strong. There are of course more
subtleties to the interactions between the
molecules that determine what state the carbon
dioxide takes, but the result is that liquid CO2
only forms at pressures above 5.11 atmospheres.
The following link will give you the phase diagram
for carbon dioxide. A phase diagram is a graph
showing what phase a material will take given a
certain pressure and temperature. Those are the
two factors that determine a compounds phase (in
normal circumstances anyways... there is a plasma
state, but let's not get into that just yet).
Temperature gives energy to the molecules, making
them want to break apart, and pressure squeezes
molecules together, making them want to arrange
themselves in an ordered fashion so as to take up
the least space possible.
I hope the diagrams on Answer #1 clear a few
things up.
Click Here to return to the search form.
|
|
|
|
|
Copyright © 2020 The Regents of the University of California,
All Rights Reserved.
UCSB Terms of Use
|
|
|