|
Why some planets have rings and others do not? |
Question Date: 2014-04-30 | | Answer 1:
There's actually still scientific dispute about
the exact answer to this question. The solar
system formed from a giant cloud of gas and
particles (literally stardust--the remains of a
star that had exploded) billions of years ago. The
"dust" clumped together to form the planets. Some
of the leftover dust formed the moons of the
planets (although the origin of Earth's moon is
still up for debate). Some of this dust was too
close to the planet to form stable moons, and
instead formed rings. It is likely that large
rings couldn't form on inner planets (Mercury,
Venus, Earth, Mars) because the rings are made of
frozen icy dust, and the sun is too hot this close
to it for the rings to form. Additional fact: Mars
has two moons, one of which is very close to the
planet. Some astrophysicists predict that it will
break apart and become a ring over the next 50
million years.
| | Answer 2:
Good question. The answer seems to be that there
are small moons orbiting ringed planets at or near
the distance from the planets as the rings
themselves, and that these moons are needed to
keep the rings from flying apart. So, basically,
having enough moons the right distance from the
planet makes rings possible.
I don't think we know why some planets have
lots of moons while others have only a few,
although I do notice that the gas giant planets in
our solar system (Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, and
Neptune) all have many moons, while the smaller
rocky planets (Mercury, Venus, Earth, Mars) have
only one or two, if any. I guess it has to do with
mass. However, Pluto and Eris, the two largest of
the ice planets, have moons, despite both being
smaller than Mercury, which has none.
| | Answer 3:
That’s a really good question! I had to do some
research on this question. I wasn’t able to find a
conclusive answer, but I have a hypothesis (an
“educated guess”). There are a few important
observations:
1) The “inner planets” (Mercury,
Venus, Earth, Mars) don’t have rings and all of
the “outer planets” (Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, and
Neptune) do.
2) The outer planets are much more
massive than the inner planets. Uranus is the
smallest of the outer planets, yet it is nearly 15
times more massive than Earth, and Jupiter is over
300 times more massive than Earth (NASA; click
here).
Objects with a lot of mass have big
“gravity” wells, meaning that they exert a bigger
“pull” on other objects. Because the outer planets
are more massive, they have bigger “gravity wells”
than the smaller inner planets. Space debris, such
as small bits of rock and ice, get caught in the
big gravity wells of the outer planets. When they
are in the gravity well of an outer planet, like
Saturn, they start to orbit the planet. The debris
have enough momentum that they don’t get pulled
all the way into the planet, instead they orbit
around it. Perhaps the smaller planets don’t have
large enough gravity wells for big ring of debris
to form. The sun makes up over 99% of the mass of
our solar system and has a huge gravity well. This
is why all of the planets orbit around it. Click Here to return to the search form.
|
 |
 |
 |
|
Copyright © 2020 The Regents of the University of California,
All Rights Reserved.
UCSB Terms of Use
|
|
|