|
Can you explain to me why is a ball on a string
like a planet in its orbit? |
Question Date: 2014-09-09 | | Answer 1:
Imagine you have a ball tied to the end of a
string. You hold the other end of the string and
swing around. The ball will eventually appear to
orbit around you in a circle. This is essentially
the exact same thing that is happening with a
planet in its orbit with the Sun! Gravity is a
force which constantly tries to pull the planet
into the Sun, much like the string is the force
pulling the ball towards you.
However, because the planet already has some
speed, this is enough to keep it from falling into
the Sun. If you spin faster, the ball will be
harder to hold onto the string so you would have
to pull harder. Imagine now that you are spinning
and suddenly you let go of the string—the ball
will go flying away. If the Sun suddenly lost its
gravitational pull on Earth, we would similarly go
flying away into space!
If you watch a simulation of planets orbiting
the Sun, you may notice that the orbit is not a
perfect circle, but instead more like an oval
(ellipse). This is because not only does the Sun’s
gravity pull on the planets, but the planets’
gravity also pulls on the Sun! Over time, planets
develop an elliptical orbit. Imagine this is like
using a bowling ball instead of small ball, and
having a long elastic rubber band instead of a
rigid string—you will be pulled towards the
bowling ball because it’s really heavy, and as you
spin around the rubber band will stretch and
compress to make an oval orbit.
| | Answer 2:
If you throw a ball, it will keep going until it
hits a wall or the ground. However, if the ball is
on a string, it will stop once the string is
completely tight. The reason why the ball stops is
because the string exerts a force on the ball
stopping it from moving. Forces can make something
move or stop something from moving. For a planet
in orbit around the sun, the string is invisible.
That invisible string is the gravitational force
between the Earth and the sun. So imagine that at
some point a planet was moving through space, but
it got too close to the sun. But the planet wasn’t
moving directly towards the sun, it was just
moving near it. At this point the invisible string
became strong and the planet kept moving around it
like a tether ball around a pole. Because the
planet had an initial speed near the sun, it kept
moving around it rather than just being pulled
directly into the sun.
| | Answer 3:
A ball on a string is an example of a model that
we use to make unfamiliar phenomena (e.g., a
planet's orbit) familiar via an everyday object.
In fact, I recommend trying it out yourself by
tying some string to a ball and swinging it around
(don't let go!). What path does the ball take?
Whenever you start a physics problem, you
always want to make sure to get a physical
understanding of it. One of the best ways to
visualize this is through a free body diagram,
where you draw out all the forces acting on the
object of interest. A force is a vector, so both
direction and magnitude are important. Below is
the free body diagram for a planet in circular orbit.
circular
orbit
Two things are happening. The planet is moving
in straight line with some velocity and gravity is
continually pulling in the planet towards the
center (e.g., sun). This gravitational pull can
also be characterized as a centripetal force,
since the resulting motion is circular
(technically a planet's orbit is not circular,
mostly because it feels the gravitational pull of
all the other planets, so it's not a simple two
body problem).
Now what if instead of gravity that was
connecting the planet and the sun, it was a piece
of string? The diagram looks pretty much the same;
the only thing we've changed is what is
responsible for force that pulls the object
towards the center to make a circular motion. With
a string attached to a ball, the force is tension.
You can read a little more about it here: click
to read
and learn a bit about some paradoxes people have
been thinking about the development of the
universe.
Physics is full of toy models that make
understanding complex phenomena easier to
understand intuitively. Another famous toy model
that we use to describe physical phenomena are
springs, known as the harmonic oscillator.
The most common example that you probably know is
a pendulum (like one on a grandfather clock that
swings back and forth to keep the time). The math
that describes the motion of a pendulum can also
describe bonds in a molecule, lattice vibrations
and thermal properties in a crystal, RLC circuits,
and many more! It's all the same math with just a
different physical interpretation. In fact, you
can find the harmonic oscillator model up until
quantum mechanics. I use it many times in the
research I'm doing to understand how lattice
vibrations in a crystal affects electrical
conduction. Even though the harmonic oscillator
can't capture everything about a system
accurately, it is extremely useful to understand
the physics without having to do much math, and
that is equally as valuable.
Hope this helps!
Best,
| | Answer 4:
Let’s start by talking about “forces”. You might
have heard the term before (since forces are all
around you), but maybe you don’t know exactly what
a force is. Basically, a force takes something
moving one way and tries to move it in another
way. For example, if you jump in the air, you
start moving upward. Eventually, the force of
gravity changes your direction from up toward to
sky to back toward the ground. If you were chasing
a ball and you ran into a wall, you would feel a
force from the wall making you move away from the
ball.
A ball on a string is also experiencing a
force. If you take a ball on a string and dangle
it so that it is hovering over the ground, the
string will tighten and the ball will stay in the
air. The ball feels a force from gravity and an
equal and opposite force from the string. When you
start spinning the ball over your head, you are
making the ball want to go to the right or the
left. But as soon as the ball goes too far to the
right or left, the force on the string pulls the
ball back to you. You could imagine this movement
like a staircase that goes in a circle. As the
steps on the staircase become very tiny, you
eventually can’t see each step.
This is a good analogy for planets in orbit
because planets feel like they are attached to the
sun by a string. Just like gravity pulls you back
toward the ground, planets and stars feel gravity
from each other. The sun, being really massive, is
like you holding the string to the ball. The force
of the string is gravity, and the ball is the
earth. Earth flies through space at 67,108 miles
per hour but the “string” attached to the sun
keeps pulling it back toward the sun – just like
tiny staircases again. The string and ball analogy
works really well in other ways, too. For example,
it can be used to help predict about how fast a
planet might be moving. It’s not perfect though;
the planets don’t actually orbit the sun in a
perfect circle. Still, it helps people understand
the basics of how an orbit works.
Best,
| | Answer 5:
A planet is pulled by the gravity of its star
toward it, but it has enough forward motion of its
own to keep from falling into its star. As a
result, it does loops around the star, not having
enough of its own motion to escape the star
completely, but enough to keep it from falling in.
If you want a better analogy, think about a marble
rolling around the inside of a funnel. If the
marble has enough forward motion, it will orbit
around the hole in the bottom of the funnel. This
is almost exactly what planets do.
| | Answer 6:
It's because the forces acting on the ball are
the same, I'll explain this, but look at this as
an example:
click here
There are two forces on the ball in this
example. One is inertia, the object continuing to
move in the direction it was going, in a straight
line (shown as v). If the string were to break,
the ball would fly away in a straight line. The
other is the force applied by the string, holding
the ball to your hand so that it can't fly away
even though it wants to as you spin. For a planet,
it has the same inertial force. If the sun were to
disappear (like the string breaking), the planet
would fly away into space in a straight line. But
gravity keeps a planet pulled in toward the sun
like the string, so it moves in a circle.
Click Here to return to the search form.
|
|
|
|
|
Copyright © 2020 The Regents of the University of California,
All Rights Reserved.
UCSB Terms of Use
|
|
|