|
It is known that living cells can, to some
extent, repair their DNA. Do you think this
process can be done without using some form of
energy?
|
Question Date: 2004-04-15 | | Answer 1:
DNA repair mechanisms are a common and
important part of cellular life. There are a
number of "sensing" mechanisms that a cell may use
to detect DNA damage. If the damage is
irreparable,these cells often undergo cell death
by a process called "apoptosis." In fact,
many cancers are thought to be the results of
"mistakes" in the sensing and checking processes
-- a cell with damaged/mutated DNA is able to
escape death and thus becomes cancerous.
As you might imagine, the DNA repair
machinery(which is fairly well described and
studied) in the cell involves enzymes that can
cut and re-ligate the
nucleic acid strands. And this requires energy to
do so. To my knowledge, there is no form of DNA
repair that does not require energy. I am
curious as to why you ask the question --does
it have something to do with the idea that DNA
replication has such high fidelity and is
a"template" directed process? Or that it is a
biological polymer that might be described as"self
healing"?
| | Answer 2:
DNA repair, like every active cellular
process, requires energy. In fact,the laws
of physics tell us that everything, every single
thing, that maintains order in the universe
requires energy.
DNA with a specific sequence is more orderly than
DNA with a random sequence, so energy must be
spent to maintain that order. Keeping your room
clean is maintaining order,too, and it also
requires energy. That energy comes to you in the
form of the food you eat. In the case of DNA
repair, the energy comes from the heat required to
keep the repair enzymes active, and in the ATP
that goes into breaking and reforming the bonds
that hold the DNA molecules together.
Questions like yours are why it's important
for biology students to take physics!
| | Answer 3:
Cool question. I like to keep students
thinking about the big ideas like energy.DNA
polymerase fixes mutations. Enzymes don't require
extra energy to work(though they may be
expensive to make). Energy in the form of
molecular movement is required, and the more
heat, the more movement, the more enzymatic
activity. At least until it's so hot that the
enzyme is destroyed. So enzymes themselves
don't have to be "recharged" to do their jobs, but
energy is required for them to work. Here's a
good summary of the
temperature/enzyme relationship:
energy
Of
course the big question is, "can anything be
done without some form of energy?" By
definition, no work can be done without
energy. But it's a great
idea for students to discuss apparent
contradictions as a way of exploring the different
forms of energy, energy conversion, and
entropy.
| | Answer 4:
Repairing DNA requires energy. It cannot be
done without energy. The Second Law of
Thermodynamics states that disorder (entropy) must
increase with time, and the restoration of order
in DNA therefore requires a greater expenditure of
order (releasing energy) elsewhere. Click Here to return to the search form.
|
|
|
|
|
Copyright © 2020 The Regents of the University of California,
All Rights Reserved.
UCSB Terms of Use
|
|
|