|
If spiders's web is so strong then how is it
broken so easily? |
Question Date: 2018-01-11 | | Answer 1:
Spider webs are strong in the sense that
they're strong for their extremely small
thickness. A strand of a spider web (called
spider silk) is very thin, so we can easily break
it, but if we could weave many strands together to
a thickness of a climbing rope, this
spider-web-rope would be many times stronger than
the rope, even stronger than some types of steel.
For comparison, the tensile strength (how much
pulling force along the length of something you
can apply before it breaks) of some steels are
around 400 to 800 megapascals while silk from
some spiders can have tensile strength of 1,000
megapascals. However, it is very difficult to
get enough spider silk to make a thicker cable,
and we do not yet have a way to use spider silk
for practical purposes.
Hope these help. Thank you!
| | Answer 2:
It is important to think about how much spider web
silk you are dealing with when you break through a
usual spider web. Its a really really small
amount, right? But what if you had a large
amount of web? Or a web with strands that were an
inch thick? This is why engineers describe
materials with "absolute strength", which
describes a material's ability to resist
breaking regardless of how much you have of it.
Spider silk actually has strength that is
pretty close to steel, but spider silk is also
much less dense (density = weight of something
per volume of that something). So if you had
two ropes of equal weights, one made of spider
web and one made of steel, the spider web rope
would actually be five times stronger than the
steel rope!
Hope that helps!
| | Answer 3:
spider web has an extremely high
"strength-to-weight ratio", that is, the
amount of weight that a spider web can hold up
without breaking is huge compared to the weight of
the web itself. However, an animal the size of a
spider can only hold so much web material in its
body, so the total amount of weight that a
spider's web can hold up is very small compared to
the amount of weight that, say, your body can hold
up.
It's the same principle of how a table built out
of toothpicks for legs wouldn't be able to hold up
much weight compared to a proper table. The
toothpicks are just too small.
| | Answer 4:
The ScienceLine moderator recommends the
following link on our database in which you can
find information for this question:
link 1
| | Answer 5:
The key to this is the definition of
"strength". When someone uses the word
strength, they typically mean the amount of weight
that can be lifted, or the amount of force that
can be supported. By this interpretation, spider
webs don't seem all that strong; they can be
brushed aside with only a very small force.
However, in scientific contexts (such as in
reporting strengths of materials, like spider
silk) strength is force per area supporting
that force. When we consider that spider silk
has a diameter around 0.003 mm (roughly 10 times
smaller than human hair), we can see that even a
small force will give a very large strength. In
fact,in terms of force per area, the strength
of spider silk is greater than that of many types
of steel.
Pieces of steel tend to be much larger than
pieces of spider silk though, so steel seems
stronger because it is easy to consider only the
force (and not the force per area) taken to break
a piece of steel. A discussion of the structure of
spider silk which leads to this strength can be
found in
previous ScienceLine answers.
| | Answer 6:
This is a really interesting question because
people always mention that the silk that makes a
spider’s web is roughly as strong as steel. If
that is true, how come we can break it so
easily? The truth is that spider’s silk is
very strong but there just is not very much of it
in a web. In fact, an average strand in a web is
only one tenth the width of a human hair. Since
there is so little silk it is easy for us to break
it in the same way that it is easy to snap a twig
in half but not a tree. If we had enough spider
silk it would be as strong as a steel beam while
weighing significantly less. Thank you for
your question! | | Answer 7:
A spider’s silk is around 3 micrometers (0.003
millimeters) in diameter, so it is very thin. It
is useful to think of a rope made of many threads
as an analogy. A single thread could never hold up
a person, but by intertwining many threads into a
rope, it can easily support the weight of a human.
When we say how strong something is, we
usually mean its tensile strength, which
measures how much stress a material can withstand
before breaking. A single strand of spider silk is
strong for its size and can withstand the force of
an insect that flies into it. If we could somehow
scale up the spider silk to be 100 times thicker
(0.3 millimeters) by constructing a rope of spider
silk, it would have a strength comparable a 22
gauge steel wire. Click Here to return to the search form.
|
|
|
|
|
Copyright © 2020 The Regents of the University of California,
All Rights Reserved.
UCSB Terms of Use
|
|
|