|
If we all came from a single cell, that is we have
evolved from one single cell which went through
rapid cell division. How is it possible for a
single cell which has no brain to think on it's
own and become a monkey or a dinosaur or something
else? Even if you say it evolved during it's cell
division, How is it possible? Because it is the
first cell, it can't have genetic variations and
so on. |
Question Date: 2018-05-17 | | Answer 1:
This is an extremely important question for
understanding life . The idea of descent with
modification explains many things in biology, like
why whales have hips, why bacteria are becoming
resistant to antibiotics, why house cats look a
lot like tigers, or why vertebrate embryos all
look really similar in the earliest stages.
It looks like you have some misunderstandings
about evolution. This is very common. First,
individuals don’t evolve. Populations do. When
gene frequencies change over time, that’s
evolution. Gene frequency is how common certain
varieties of genes (alleles) are.
There’s a lot of variation between individuals in
any population. This is due to random mutation
(errors when DNA copies itself). We notice
variation in humans, but it’s true for salmon and
pine trees and bread yeast too. Even when single
cells divide, their DNA can undergo mutation. Any
population not made of clones has a lot of
variation. Some of those differences in genes
don’t affect an individual’s chances of
reproducing. Some improve its chances. Some
decrease its chances.
Here’s an example, if brownish pocket mice
colonize a black rock area, some will already be
darker than others, just due to random variation.
The ones that are darker are probably more likely
to survive and reproduce on the black rocks
because predators can’t see them. So dark ones
have more babies, passing on more dark genes.
After a while it will be very rare to see any
light mice.
Here’s another important fact, evolution
does not
happen because something decides to evolve. We
humans are pretty darn smart, but we can’t change
ourselves into other species. Mutations do not
happen because of trying, or needing them, or
wanting them. Mutations are totally random.
Natural selection, the process in which
individuals with genetic advantages are more
likely to pass on their genes, is NOT random.
So when the first cells were dividing, their DNA
copied itself. Mutations would have occurred. As
the cells spread and multiplied, some of those
cells would have had advantages for particular
conditions and places. Imagine that some cells
ended up in colder water. Cells with genes that
help them survive in colder water would have had
an advantage there. Every now and again, some
random mutation may have happened that made them
even better at living in cold water, and worse at
living in warmer water. Eventually, the cold and
warm water populations would become very
different. They didn’t decide to do anything.
Random mutation created variation and cells with
helpful mutations were more likely to keep
dividing, leaving more cells with the variations
that are helpful.
Single-cell organisms can exchange DNA,
but let’s
fast forward to multicellular species. As
populations get isolated from each other due to
geographic, climate, geological changes, and major
mutations, they become so different that they
can’t interbreed anymore and become different
species. We can trace which species are more or
less closely related by counting the number of
differences in their DNA . By knowing the average
number of mutations per a period of time, we can
estimate how long ago two lines started changing in
different directions. Evidence from the fossil
record helps validate our estimates. For example,
tigers and house cats are the descendants of an
extinct species of cat that lived about 11 million
years ago. House cats and cheetahs are both
descended from an extinct cat species that lived
about 6 million years ago. By the way, we did not
descend from chimps or any other living species,
we just share common ancestors.
Can you think of examples of species that are in
the process of becoming so different that they
don’t usually reproduce, but they still can under
certain circumstances? Try looking at
hybrid species.
Thanks for asking,
| | Answer 2:
I believe you are asking about how
multicellularity evolved which is a very
interesting field of research!
Our bodies are made up of cells that have
specific jobs. Your heart cells have to
rhythmically beat, cells in your intestines have
to absorb nutrients, and brain cells have to
secrete signals and communicate with each
other…the list goes on and on. How did all of
this cellular diversity arise?, and
furthermore how do these cells come together
and form an entire organism like a monkey or a
dinosaur!?
Single celled organisms are still around
and thriving today. Some people argue that
they can make “decisions”; a simple example is a
motile cell that will move toward a source of
nutrients or away from heat. Single-celled
organisms can be quite complex; look up
Tetrahymena. It breeds with other
Tetrahymena which leads to the exchange of genetic
information. Even bacteria can have sex so this,
as you allude to, provides an increased
opportunity for evolutionary selection to take
place. So, what selected for single cells to
stay together? Nowadays there is still
evidence of this taking place: microbial
mats (you can look that up too). Some single
celled organisms will come together and form
complex layers (“mats”). Depending on where the
microbe is situated in this configuration, it can
have a different job, like making and secreting
different molecules to communicate with other
bacteria, or absorbing and processing things from
the environment. This division of labor among the
same species of bacteria is similar to how all our
different cell types (which all contain exactly
the same genetic information) make up a
functioning body.
This is a link to a really cool video narrated
by Sir David Atenborough who explains the history
of life:
history of life
| | Answer 3:
You're confusing growth with evolution.
Every cell in your body has the exact same
genetic
makeup, except for your sperm (if you are male) or
eggs (if you are female), which have half the DNA
of any of your other cells. Your cells respond to
certain stimuli, such as temperature, light, or
chemicals, and proteins inside of the cell then
tell the cell to do things, which can include
sending other chemical signals to other cells.
This is how your cells "know" to divide or not to
divide, or what to turn into, be it muscle,
nerves, etc. Cells do have Golgi aparati, which
act as a sort of nerve center within a cell, but
they still need information from the outside in
order to specialize to build your multicellular
body, and that information comes from either
environmental effects or from chemical signals
from other cells.
Evolution is the change in the DNA of a
lineage.
Because all of your cells have the same DNA, your
cells are not evolving, and neither is your body.
You cannot evolve. The human species can
evolve,
but only because your children do not have the
same DNA as you do (in particular, they will have
half of their DNA from you, and half from your
husband or wife).
The ancestor of all animals did have only a single
cell. By evolving, that species of protozoan began
to be able to send chemical signals to other
members of its species, and in time they began to
organize themselves into larger and larger groups.
Eventually, the signals they were sending became
complex enough and the cells' responses became
complex enough that some cells behaved in a
different way and turned into different types of
cells from the others in their population. This is
how multicellularity evolved. All of the cells in
a multicellular animal are still descended from a
single cell, however, and that cell is the product
of a sperm meeting an egg from a previous
generation. Your father, for example, is a
multicellular animal, and your mother is also a
multicellular animal, but your father's sperm and
your mother's egg combined to create a single
cell: you. You then divided into multiple cells.
That was not evolution, but growth. The only
evolution that happened was when the half of your
father's DNA combined with the half of your
mother's DNA combined to become your DNA, which
makes you different from your parents. However,
the process by which single-celled protozoans
evolved into multicellular animals was not simply
growth, and involved many generations, and many
combinations of sperm with egg.
As for what a zygote (a cell created by
the union
of sperm and egg) turns into, it depends on the
cell's DNA. Your DNA told the zygote that was you
to become a human, because you have human DNA. A
monkey zygote has monkey DNA that tells it to grow
into a monkey, and a dinosaur zygote has dinosaur
DNA that tells it to grow into a dinosaur. The
exact way in which this happens varies from animal
to animal (and from plant to plant, since they use
an analogous system), and many of the details of
how it happens remain unknown. What we do know is
that there are cascades of regulatory
genes, where
gene A activates genes B, C, and D, while gene D
then activates E, F, and G, and so on.
| | Answer 4:
At the most fundamental level, evolution is always
acting on genes - whether or not you're looking at
monkeys, humans, avocados, or bacteria, the traits
that make an organism more or less adapted to
their surroundings are dictated by the DNA.
Single-celled organisms such as bacteria don't
live in isolation. They can compete with each
other (some inject their neighbors with toxins,
for example) or cooperate with each other. Over
millions of years, colonies of single-celled
(genetically identical) organisms eventually
became tissues that could out-compete their
non-cooperative neighbors for resources. Over
time, these tissues became organs that were
interdependent on one another for specific
functions. Ultimately, the function of every
single one of our complex organs is to get our
genes into the next generation; our cells have
simply evolved a much more complicated way of
getting there.
| | Answer 5:
It is important to remember that evolution
occurs on geological timescales that are much
longer than humans can observe. Here is an
example: I am sitting in Santa Barbara, California
right now, and I don’t feel that I am moving at
all. But if I could somehow fast-forward time I
would see that I am actually sitting on a
continental plate that is mobile and drifting
across a sea of mantle. Here is a picture of just
the last 250 million years
continental drift
If I could go back several hundred million
years, the land where I am sitting now would
actually be in Antarctica. The reason I don’t see
the continents moving is because they move too
slow compared to human perception.
Evolution occurs on the same geological
timescales. A single cell did not become a monkey
or a human, it lived and divided, passing on its
genetic material. From its perspective nothing
changed. The first single-celled organisms
appeared 3.5 billion years ago, but the first
multicellular organisms didn’t appear until 600
million years ago. That is an incredibly long time
even by evolutionary standards. For almost 3
billion years there were only single-celled
organisms. Evolution proceeds by natural
selection, meaning that the cells which had a
better chance of survival were more likely to pass
on their genetic information. No one knows
exactly what triggered the arrival of
multicellular organisms. One can speculate
that eventually, different cells began
specializing and cooperating in a symbiotic
relationship, which was mutually beneficial to
both cells. These cooperating cells were more
likely to survive and pass on their genes, and
eventually, over millions of years these
cooperating cells became the earliest
multicellular organisms. Again, it is important to
realize that this occurs on geological timescales.
Scientists use the fossil record which
provides snapshots which are like still frames in
this fast-forward movie of time. No single
organism decides to become a monkey or a dinosaur;
evolution occurs through natural selection which
only becomes noticeable after many generations. Click Here to return to the search form.
|
|
|
|
|
Copyright © 2020 The Regents of the University of California,
All Rights Reserved.
UCSB Terms of Use
|
|
|