|
Are dolphins more intelligent compared to other
species and or humans? I'm asking this question
because I know that dolphins have a bigger brain
and use echolocation which is advanced compared to
other species. I also want to know why humans and
only humans are the only living animal that has
been able to speak and live and thrive in this world. |
Question Date: 2018-10-22 | | Answer 1:
Dolphins are amazing, aren't they? We know
that they can solve problems, understand some
complex communication from us, and they do have a
big brain, even if you count in their size.
They also pass the self-awareness test of
recognizing themselves in mirrors. In fact,
dolphins seem to be able to do this at 7 months,
while humans can't do this until they are a year
old. Chimps don't recognize themselves until
they're two years old. There are very few animals
that can do that. Most treat their reflections as
other individuals or simply ignore them after a
while.
Evaluating who is more intelligent is not as
easy as it sounds because there are many
different ways to show intelligence. As you say,
echolocation is a pretty awesome skill. Bats have
it too. Obviously, we usually don't, but humans
can learn to do a bit of it. Even measuring
intelligence within our own species is
controversial. One person may be able to fix
anything, another can play complex music after
hearing it once, someone else can beat everyone at
chess, another understands complicated emotions
and behaviors of other people. Who is
smarter? It all depends on how you decide
to test intelligence.
It might seem like intelligence is always a
good thing, but there are a few reasons why we
don't expect all animals to be smart. One is that
there's a trade-off between being born (or
hatched) with a complete set of behaviors that
usually work and having to learn most of your
behaviors. Animals that don't live long don't
have time to learn anything. On the other hand,
that can't adjust to changing conditions. Smarter
animals can solve new problems and make all sorts
of adjustments, but it takes them a long time to
learn and they may need protection, or even
teaching, while they learn. Brains are
expensive in terms of the energy they use, so
animals don't usually have more brains than they
need. What do the smart animals have in
common? One thing is they live a long
time. Another is that they usually live in
groups. Figuring out how to interact with
others is complicated.
We think of speech as being very advanced
because language is such a powerful tool. It
allows us to communicate, obviously, but it also
allows us to think and plan. Writing lets us
remember and even pass knowledge down through many
generations. Human speech is not the only kind of
speech, though. Many animals have complex
communication, even if we don't always understand
it.
There are hundreds of millions of species on
Earth, living and thriving without speech. What
are some of the strategies that make them
successful?
Thanks for asking,
| | Answer 2:
Well, humans are not the only animal that speak
and live and thrive - we speak to a greater degree
than most other animals, but there are other
animals that communicate.
As for dolphins, they are very intelligent. I'm
not sure we know that they're the
second-most-intelligent; there are a lot of other
very intelligent animals as well, so dolphins have
a lot of competition. Having a large brain does
help with intelligence, but it isn't the only
factor. For example, octopus are about as
intelligent as most mammals, but their brains are
no larger than those of most fish.
| | Answer 3:
It’s true that dolphins have one of the largest
brains measured lb brain mass
per lb body mass , but there are many other
animals which use echolocation
such as bats, whales, shrews, swiftlets, and
oilbirds. I would hesitate to say
dolphins are “more intelligent” than other animals
because measures of
intelligence are subjective, or that use of
echolocation makes an animal “more
advanced” than another animal because adaptations
are simply a product of
the environment an animal lives in.
Certainly, dolphins in captivity have been trained
successfully to do all kinds of
tricks, and even to solve puzzles which makes them
a fascinating species to
interact with. On the other hand, crows have also
exhibited an ability to problem
solve, and use tools.
In 2018, the BBC reported on a recent
experiment where
New Caledonian crows were able to learn to use
fishing hooks and vending
machines. So dolphins are not the only animals
which exhibit these abilities.
Similarly, echolocation is an amazing, specialized
adaptation that allows
dolphins to hunt in environments where visibility
is not always good. But other
animals use these same techniques as I mentioned
before, and still others
have other specialized skills - for example,
salmon travel hundred of miles from
the open ocean back to the exact river bed where
they hatched and nobody
knows how they do it. Since evolution of species
involves multiple branchings
based on the conditions each organism lived in,
it is difficult to say whether one
species is “more advanced” than another,
especially when you are looking at
the entire animal kingdom.
Many species of animals thrive on planet Earth,
and many have their own ways
of communicating with each other whether through
sound, body language, or
even chemical excretions. However, the question
of why and how humans
developed complex spoken language is still a topic
of debate among
evolutionary biologists and linguists. Some
theories include that language was
developed to facilitate trade, or it spontaneously
developed from more
rudimentary systems of communication as they
naturally grew in complexity.
The study of language is called
linguistics, and it’s a fascinating field
that sits at
the intersection of history, biology and genetics,
and humanities. Maybe one
day you will make a discovery about how ancient
humans developed language! Click Here to return to the search form.
|
|
|
|
|
Copyright © 2020 The Regents of the University of California,
All Rights Reserved.
UCSB Terms of Use
|
|
|