Answer 1:
This is a great question!
Let’s start with how water and plants interact and
then we’ll talk about the color portion of your
experiment.
When plants photosynthesis, they open the
stomata on their leaves to bring in carbon
dioxide (which they use with energy from the sun
to grow). At the same time, when their stomata are
open, they release oxygen and water molecules
to the air. The process is called
transpiration. When the water molecules
leave the plant, a “chain” is created that
pulls water molecules from the soil into the
roots, from the roots into the stem,
and from the stem into the leaves. I think
about this interaction like a drinking straw with
me being the atmosphere creating the “pull” that’s
pulling the chain of water molecules from the soil
(cup of water), through the plant (drinking
straw), and into the atmosphere (my mouth).
Now what happens if I’m drinking water with a
powdered drink mix or food dye? Well, my straw
is pretty big and all the powdered drink mix or
food dye pass easily through the straw into my
mouth. But in a plant, the straws (xylem)
are much smaller and, while water molecules easily
move through the plant and out the stomata, the
food dye molecules get “stuck” and are left
behind in the plant, thus coloring your
plant.
Ok, now on to your experiment with dye and
radishes. The exciting thing is – I don’t know
what would happen either! Using a plant with a
light color (e.g., a plant with a white flower) is
the easiest way to see if your dye stains the
plant. But radishes have green leaves and the
only white part of the plant is underground!
Would the color stain the outside of the
radish? Probably, because it’s growing in soil
surrounded by colored water (similar to dying
eggs). Would the color stain the inside of the
radish? That’s an interesting question! I’d
guess that the radish leaves would turn color too
(because the food dye molecules will be present in
the leaves) but I’m not sure if the color will
be visible within a green leaf.
As for affecting the growth of radishes, I don’t
think food dye would have an effect because I
think of food dye as being benign – we eat it all
the time without effects to our health. However, a
powdered drink mix has a ton of other stuff –
sugar, artificial flavors, added supplements, etc.
and I don’t know how those additives would
affect the growth of a plant. Plus not all
food dyes are the same. I wonder if there’s a
difference between sources of the food dye…?
A few comments on your experiment –
1) What do you think will happen to your
radishes if you water them with colored water? Do
you think they’ll grow bigger leaves? Will the
leaves change color? Will the radish bulb change
color? Will it grow a smaller bulb?
Creating an educated guess (hypothesis)
on what will happen during your experiment is
important to identify so you can collect the
appropriate data. (e.g., if you think the
leaves will change color – make a color
scale to quantify leaf “greenness”. If you
think the leaves will grow bigger – measure the
length and width of the leaves. If you think
the bulb will be smaller – measure the height
and width, or the radius of each bulb.
2) Make sure you have a
control so you can verify the impact of
your food dye treatments. For example, have a
treatment where you water your radishes with only
one difference – no food dye. This way you
can be confident that the differences you observe
in your radishes are due to the addition of food
dye and not to different sources of water, more
sunlight, type of soil, etc.
Good luck! I’m excited for you and your
project.
All the best,
|