|
My neighbor is purchasing a deck canopy tent. His
choice of colors are white or blue. I suggested
that white will attract less heat from the sun
than blue. Is this correct |
Question Date: 2019-07-05 | | Answer 1:
In brief, you are correct [if I am interpreting
the question correctly], but other factors mean
that your neighbor should probably get the blue
canopy.
While neither color will "attract" heat from the
sun, the white canopy should be cooler. The
color of an object/material is determined by
the wavelengths of light which are
not absorbed (i.e., those that are
reflected or transmitted).
Eyes can only detect the light which
is there, and absorbed light is no longer
"traveling around" to reach the sight receptors.
White light, sunlight being one example, comprises
light with wavelengths in the visible spectrum in
approximately equal fractions. Any object (such as
the tent canopy) which
reflects all of those wavelengths
appear white. In contrast, an object
which reflects only some of those wavelengths will
have a different color which depends on the
wavelengths reflected. The blue color of the
second canopy means that the visible light in the
"blue" portion of the spectrum is reflected; the
light of other wavelengths is absorbed. Absorbing
this light transfers energy to the fabric of the
canopy, raising the temperature. [Aside - color
does not affect absorption of infrared light,
commonly thought of as heat. Any heating due to
light in that regime will be approximately the
same between the two canopies and can be omitted
from consideration here.]
However, this does not mean that your neighbor
should get the white canopy. Although the
temperature of the canopy (meaning the material of
the tent) will likely be higher for the blue than
for the white, the same may not be true of the
people underneath it. The white canopy will absorb
less light, meaning also that it will emit less
heat, than the blue canopy. (Note that this is
because the blue canopy is warmer, not due to a
relation between color [visible light] and
thermal emissivity [infrared light]: white
and blue canopies of the same temperature would
emit nearly the same amount of thermal
energy.) A person very close to the canopy would
feel warmer with the blue canopy than with the
white one. However, while the white canopy absorbs
less light, one consequence is that it transmits
more light than the blue canopy (see links above).
The transmitted light will then reach and be
absorbed by the people and furniture underneath
the canopy, heating them directly. In other words,
the blue canopy will block more of the sun's
light (be darker or "shadier") than the white
canopy.
The temperature under the canopy ultimately
depends on the combination of the heating due to
emission from the canopy material and that from
the transmitted light. If the tent is open such
that a breeze can get through, then the air warmed
by the hotter blue canopy will not reach the
occupants. This is essentially the same as the
principle which
keeps Bedouins cool despite their
wearing black clothing. In this case, the blue
canopy, which blocks more of the transmitted
light, will likely give a cooler tent despite the
tent fabric itself being warmer. Given that many
people use electronic devices outside, your
neighbor might also consider that readability of
screens will be better with the lower transmitted
light of the blue canopy. In addition, darker
colors may offer better
protection from UV light.
| | Answer 2:
White will reflect more light than blue,
but white will also emit less light than
blue. Overall, I'd say that white is probably
better, but it's probably going to depend in part
on how reflective the two tents are in the
infrared and ultraviolet, too, so I'm not sure
what the best answer is. | | Answer 3:
Yup - white reflects heat. Darker colors
absorb heat. I 'like' the experience, barefoot in
a hot outdoor parking lot, when the white lines
are cooler than the black parking spaces.
On the other hand, there is this question: "Why
do Bedouins wear black robes in hot deserts?"
here
So maybe your neighbors can purchase which ever
color they prefer, because "The additional heat
absorbed by the black robe was lost before it
reached the skin." | | Answer 4:
That is correct! The color that appears on an
object is the color that object is
reflecting. Green grass, for example, reflects
green light. However, it also means that the
object is absorbing every other color. So
green grass is absorbing red, blue, yellow, and
every other color that it isn’t. Color in this
case is a form of light, and light is a form of
energy, and energy produces heat. So you can
imagine the more colors absorbed by the object,
the hotter the object gets. Pure black and white
are interesting, however. Black absorbs all
color wavelengths and white absorbs none.
Now let’s look at your specific question. A blue
canopy is going to reflect blue light, but absorb
red, green, yellow, orange, purple, and every
other wavelength of color. White however is
special, because it reflects every wavelength of
light and absorbs none. This means that white will
reflect the most light and is the best option for
keeping the deck cool! | | Answer 5:
You are correct. Colors of things are based
on the wavelength of light it reflects. The
different wavelengths of visible light combine
into white light. So, a white object reflects all
wavelengths of visible light, while a blue object
will only reflect the blue wavelength of light,
and absorb radiation from all the other
wavelengths. Click Here to return to the search form.
|
|
|
|
|
Copyright © 2020 The Regents of the University of California,
All Rights Reserved.
UCSB Terms of Use
|
|
|