|
I am doing a science project with plants. Two
tomato plants are grown under boxes made of four
types of cellophane: red, green, blue and clear.
The red one grew the most, both in height and
width, then the clear followed by the green, then
the blue. Why did it turn out this way?
|
Question Date: 2002-03-21 | | Answer 1:
I remember doing an experiment very similar to
this one when I was in high school. My results
were a little different than yours so I think that
there may be factors that affect the growth of
plants other than light at work in our
experiments. I used a single celled plant (I don't
remember what it was anymore) and found that they
grew best in red light, then clear (though the red
and clear were almost the same), then blue, then
green. You may already know that plants get
their energy from sunlight and that sunlight
contains all the colors. To get turn light into
energy the plant can use, plants have a special
molecule called chlorophyll. It turns out
that the
molecule works best with red light, and works a
little with blue light, but not very well with
green light. That is why plants look green. The
green light in the sunlight gets reflected back
into your eyes. The red and blue light are
absorbed by the chlorophyll and used for energy. I
would expect the clear cellophane to work about as
well as red cellophane since clear cellophane
contains lots of red light also. I hope that
helps. | | Answer 2:
You let your plants all have the same kind of
soil, and the same water. What did you
change? The
kind of light. Light is what the plant uses to
make its food from carbon dioxide (that it gets
from the air). Plants use a certain colors of
light much more than others, mostly blue and some
red. So plants absorb (take in) blue and red
light. That is why they look green! It's
because plants reflect green light and absorb the
other colors. The cellophane you used blocks out
the color of light that it appears to be, and lets
the rest through. The red cellophane blocks out
red light, and lets blue light through. The plant
covered with red cellophane got the most blue
light, so that plant had the most energy to grow.
The clear cellophane-covered plant should have
gotten about as much blue light, so it should have
been nearly as big.
Maybe giving a plant ONLY blue
light makes it easier for it to grow somehow. The
green cellophane probably blocked out some of the
blue light that plants use (look at a rainbow -
green is very close to blue. They are similar
colors) When they make green cellophane they
probably add yellow dye to same mix they use for
blue cellophane. So the green and blue cellophane
block out the blue light and those plants have the
least energy to grow.
| | Answer 3:
Plant leaves absorb more light of certain colors
than others. Given that the color of opaque
objects, like the green leaves, is determined by
the light that they reflect, rather than absorb,
which color(s) do you think the plant leaves
absorb the most? Does that make sense with which
plants grew the most?
As an interesting aside,
green-leafed plants were not always dominant on
Earth. The spectrum of sunlight reaching the
Earth's surface is peaked around green, such that
there is sun's light is more intense in the greens
and yellows than it is in the reds, blues, or
purples. Ancient plants evolved to make the
most of the light arriving from the sun, and so
absorbed green light. The leaves of these ancient
plants would probably have appeared purplish in
color. The green-leafed plants evolved to use the
light that the majority of the plants then
reflected and did not absorb. If you're curious,
you can investigate to find out when the
purple-leafed plants died out, and why. There are
still some plants that have purple, rather than
green, leaves. Can you think of some?
| | Answer 4:
I would hate to give you the answer, as the point
of doing a science project is to look at the
results and think for yourself what they mean.
First of all, you must know something about how
plants absorb light or you wouldn't have chosen
this project. The clear cellophane is letting all
colors of light pass through. The colored
cellophane is letting light of only one color pass
through. Plants absorb light and convert it to
chemical energy, which they use for growth. Plants
don't absorb all colors equally, though, and which
color of light they absorb the most depends on
which light-absorbing pigments the plant has. For
the most part, land plants use chlorophyll-a to
absorb light. Chlorophyll-a has a specific
chemical structure that absorbs red and blue light
more than green (which, by the way, is why plants
look green: the green light is reflected rather
than absorbed). Red, especially, is
absorbed.
Here are some guidelines for
interpreting your results. Assume that all factors
affecting growth other than light (genetic
differences, water, soil nutrients, temperature,
pests) are the same for each plant. Then imagine
several scenarios. I'm guessing the outcome of
your experiment is a combination of
these.
1) There is enough light coming
through the cellophane so that plant growth is not
limited by light, but by some other factor.
Predict the order of growth.
2) All of the
cellophane colors, even clear, reduce the light
enough so that plant growth is limited by light.
The colored cellophane is light enough that the
main difference among the cellophane treatments is
color of light and not the intensity of light.
Knowing that plants absorb red light the most,
then blue, predict the order of growth.
3)
Some of the cellophane colors are darker than
others and so reduce the intensity of light to
very different extents. Place the cellophane
against a white background and order the colors
according to how much you think they might reduce
incoming light. Predict the order of
growth.
Plants are like animals in that
even those from the same batch of seeds (the same
"parents") can have very different individual
growth rates. To account for this, you would need
to keep some "control" plants (say four extra
plants) nearby but without cellophane, and measure
their growth. If the differences in growth among
the four plants without cellophane are similar to
the differences among the four plants under the
different cellophane colors, you're not looking at
the effect of cellophane color but at individual
genetic differences in the plants. The control
plants would also tell you if the clear cellophane
was reducing light, which would help with scenario
2. Click Here to return to the search form.
|
|
|
|
|
Copyright © 2020 The Regents of the University of California,
All Rights Reserved.
UCSB Terms of Use
|
|
|